Guessing game

by eero90125

A blindfolded boytaur tries to identify which of his friends is sucking each of his cocks.

The game was simple: I would be blindfolded while my friends all sucked one of my cocks, and I would have to guess who was on each one. I had lots of experience with each of these guys, so I liked my chances.

Dom was in charge of the blindfold. He wrapped it carefully around my head, being extra sure to check that I couldn’t see underneath it, especially since I would be lying down. When he was satisfied that I was really blind, he guided me to my bed where I sprawled out and got myself comfortable. Now that I was on full display, I could sense the desire of my companions building.

“All right, gents, let’s get this thing started,” I said.

All four of them immediately took their positions and got to work. My cocks were still only half-hard, so the first task was to get them to full attention. My back right cock was the first to stiffen all the way, thanks to its attendant and his skillful ministrations. He knew just how to tease me, running a finger up and down the underside of my cock and gently prodding the tip, all while stroking my rear balls with the utmost care. That must have been Kyle’s station.

Next to bone up was the back left, largely from proximity to its rock-hard neighbor. I wasn’t sure who was working on it yet, but he was doing a decent job. He was bouncing his assigned cock in his hand, feeling it harden gradually and giving it a few strokes here and there. He was using his other hand to feel up my thigh and ass, which certainly helped.

The front left had to be Frankie. Cute as a button, but never a star when it came to foreplay. He was lazily wagging my cock around, occasionally putting it into his mouth, which doesn’t do much for me before I’m completely hard. He eventually achieved optimal erectness, but not before the guy across from him worked his magic on my front right cock with some well-timed stroking.

With two of my four attendants placed, I still had to identify Dom and Will. With everyone moving into the next stage, I tried to focus on finding clues, which became much harder as Kyle took my back right cock into his mouth, expertly sliding up and down while massaging its length with his tongue. He was truly a master of the art of cocksucking, and I was only a little surprised at how easy it was to identify him. Frankie, meanwhile, who had been so pitiful at teasing me to full mast, was now doing a decent job. He kept one hand on the root of my cock as he sucked while the other alternated between massaging my front ballsack and stroking my underbelly. Waves of pleasure came over me as both crotches and the space between them received expert stimulation.

The guy on my front right member started out by jerking me off, slowly at first, then picking up to a moderate pace. His free hand drifted to my abs and started caressing them. I decided this must be Will, for two reasons. First, he knew how much I liked my abs and that giving them some attention would turn me on more; second, his hands felt fairly big. Will, being 6’3”, had much bigger hands than Dom, his 5’5” counterpart. The sensations from my back crotch confirmed this conclusion. Dom’s hands felt smaller, both the one he had on my cock and the one that was racing up and down my back left thigh.

The pleasure was starting to near a breaking point, and I was moaning and breathing heavily. Frankie took a page out of Dom’s book and abandoned my underbelly in favor of my front left thigh, which he massaged with both hands, letting his mouth do all the work on my cock. I let out a gasp as Will made the transition from stroking to sucking, letting go of my cock with his hand as he took its full length into his mouth. His left hand was still wandering over my abs, but I didn’t feel his right hand on me, which I took to mean that he was tending to his own cock on the side.

With all four achingly hard erections being sucked by masters of the craft, my head was starting to swim from the pleasure. I could feel my orgasms looming. The back cocks were the first to burst. Kyle could sense the orgasm approaching, and he took my back right cock all the way into his mouth as I came, shooting hot seed directly down his throat, which eagerly swallowed it all. Each pair of my cocks usually came near-simultaneously, and this time was no exception. Dom’s left hand stopped its movement on my leg, and his right hand abandoned my back left cock as it started shooting, presumably so he could jerk himself off as he swallowed my hot, sweet load. When both rear cocks were spent, Dom and Kyle reluctantly slid their mouths off of them and let them fall back onto my underbelly, still mostly hard and leaking dribbles of cum.

Meanwhile, Frankie had taken my front left cock out of his mouth, moving a hand from my leg to take over. I didn’t mind, though, because he was doing a good job, and it wouldn’t be long before I couldn’t hold back anymore. What finally sent me over the edge was a grunt and slight movement from Will that told me that he was cumming. The thought of it was too much to bear, and I bucked and started spraying from both front cocks at once. Will greedily swallowed his load, while the other, no longer confined within Frankie’s mouth, left hot streaks all over my torso and Will’s hand, which was still resting on my abs. When it was finished, Frankie licked the remnants from my cock and started to lap up some of the cum from my stomach. He was clearly jerking himself furiously while he did so, judging by the sounds and the moan he let out when he finally came.

My breathing finally slowed, my muscles relaxed, and my cocks, now unattended, were all softening. I lay still for a few seconds with all six limbs spread, my legs dangling lazily from the sides of my extra-long bed.

Then it was time to guess. I pushed myself back so I could sit partially upright against the wall behind my bed. Then I took one of my front cocks in each hand.

“Will,” I declared, shaking the cock in my right hand. Doing the same with the left, I said, “Frankie.”

Reaching down to my hind crotch, I repeated the process. “Kyle...and Dom.”

Will’s rich voice sounded from nearby, on the right. “A+. Gold star.”

I released my cocks and sat back with a smile and a sigh. When I removed the blindfold, I was greeted by four happy faces in exactly the places I had guessed. My friends, all covered in their own cum (or maybe each other’s), looked quite satisfied and pleased with themselves. They had certainly earned the right to be proud of their work.

“You know us too well, man,” Kyle said.

“You make it sound like that’s a problem,” Frankie countered, some of my cum dripping off of his chin. “How many guys can say they know a boytaur well enough that he knows which dick they’re sucking?”

“Fair enough,” Kyle replied.

I chuckled. “Well, thanks for this experiment, guys. It was fun. But how about letting me look at you next time? I missed seeing you while you were working.”

The others agreed. I rolled off of the bed and onto my four feet, then headed toward the bathroom to get cleaned up. The others followed, eager to help.

Vote on this story

Adam’s boyfriend by Bud Boytaurbody His truly supportive BF loves four-legged, wristfooted Adam and his equally spectacular swimmer buds. 1,969 words Added May 2002 20k views 5.0 stars (1 vote) No comments yet •Multicock•Boytaur•Four Legs•Multiarm•Multileg•Multilimb•Wristfeet•Detachable

Armfuls of feet by James Fourlegs Eric really pumps out feet for his lover. 2 parts 2,966 words Added May 2002 15k views 5.0 stars (1 vote) No comments yet •Multi-anus•Multicock•Lots of Legs•Multiarm•Multileg•Multilimb•Wristfeet

The box by BRK Steve gets a box of clothes from his mysterious and beautiful brother, Peter, and it turns out the clothes have an amazing effect on his already unusual body. 8 parts 30k words Added Dec 2002 Updated 7 Sep 2019 36k views 5.0 stars (14 votes) No comments yet •Cock Growth•Huge Cock•Public Orgasm•Extra digits•Multicock•Multihead•Four Legs•Multiarm•Multileg•Multilimb•Replication•Muscle Growth•Stretchy•Getting Handsomer•Getting Taller•First Time/Virgin•Incest•Brothers•Selfcest•Witch/Warlock/Wizard •M/M•M/M/M•M/M/M/...

Boytaur Christmas by Jefftaur Kevin gives his boyfriend the best present ever: a boytaur Christmas. 2 parts 3,590 words Added May 2002 13k views 5.0 stars (1 vote) No comments yet •Multicock•Boytaur•Four Legs•Multileg•Multilimb•Wristfeet•Christmas

Eric by Brad Mercury While working on his car, Eric finally decides to show his best friend the extras he can grow. 4 parts 4,815 words Added May 2002 16k views 5.0 stars (5 votes) No comments yet •Multicock•Four Legs•Lots of Legs•Multiarm•Multileg•Multilimb •M/M

Extra jeff by Josh Dugan You really can't get enough of Jeff even though there is so much of him. 596 words Added Sep 2005 12k views 5.0 stars (3 votes) No comments yet •Huge Cock•Multicock•Multileg•Multilimb•Replication•Wristfeet•Selfcest

Kyle’s third leg by Unknown Kyle finds an abandoned container of goo that turns his "third leg" a lot more literal. 5 parts 3,762 words Added Oct 2015 16k views 5.0 stars (2 votes) No comments yet •Extra digits•Multicock•Multileg•Multilimb•Three Legs

Transform: Fine art by Also Known As 6,999 words Added Jan 2014 9,612 views 5.0 stars (2 votes) No comments yet •Huge Cock•Multicock•Muscle Growth•Muscle/Strength•Size Increase•Infectious